You’ve landed the job! The interviews went great, the job description was perfect, and the hiring manager painted a vivid picture of career growth and exciting responsibilities. Fast forward a few months, and the reality has hit: Your job is not what you expected. If this sounds familiar, you might be a victim of a growing workplace trend known as Career Catfishing.
We’ve all heard the term “catfish.” Typically, it refers to an individual who creates a fake online identity to deceive someone, usually in the pursuit of a relationship or friendship. But the phenomenon has now entered the professional realm.
What is Career Catfishing?
Career catfishing occurs when a company, recruiter, or hiring manager significantly misrepresents a job role, work environment, or organizational culture to entice a candidate to accept an offer. In essence, they use a “fake profile” of the job to deceive you into joining the organization.
It’s more than just a minor disappointment; it’s a profound misalignment where your new role turns out to be very different from what you were promised. This professional deception can lead to stress, burnout, reduced productivity, and rapid employee turnover.
Is Career Catfishing Real? Yes, and It’s a Nationwide Problem
The short answer is yes, career catfishing is very real. While it’s not a legal term, it accurately describes a pattern of deceptive hiring practices that cost companies time and money and cause immense frustration for employees.
Why does it happen?
- Pressure to Fill Roles: Companies are often desperate to fill vacancies quickly, leading some recruiters to oversell a position.
- Focus on Retention: Employers know that once a candidate starts, they are less likely to immediately quit, even if the job is disappointing.
- Lack of Internal Communication: Sometimes the misrepresentation isn’t malicious; it’s a disconnect between what HR/recruiting is told to sell and what the department actually needs.
Understanding this deception is the first step to protecting your career path and making informed decisions about your employment opportunities.
How to Spot Career Catfishing
How can you tell if you’ve been “career catfished” instead of just having the typical “new job blues”? Look out for these significant red flags:
The Job Responsibilities Don’t Match What Was Promised
During interviews, you were told you’d be leading projects and managing a team. Now you’re doing data entry and filing paperwork. If your actual day-to-day work looks nothing like the job description you were hired for, that’s a major warning sign.
The Company Culture Is Completely Different From What They Described
They sold you on flexible schedules and work-life balance, but now you’re expected to answer emails at midnight and work weekends without question. When the workplace values they advertised disappear the moment you start, you’ve likely been misled.
Your Boss or Team Isn’t Who You Met During the Interview Process
You interviewed with an experienced manager who seemed supportive and knowledgeable. On day one, you discover they’ve left the company or you’re reporting to someone entirely different. This classic bait-and-switch leaves you without the leadership you were counting on.
The “Growth Opportunities” Were Exaggerated or Don’t Exist
They promised training programs, mentorship, and a clear path to promotion. Months later, there’s no professional development, no one has time to mentor you, and the promotion timeline keeps getting pushed back indefinitely.
Key Resources or Tools Were Oversold
You were told you’d have cutting-edge technology, a full support team, or adequate budget to do your job well. Instead, you’re working with outdated equipment, understaffed teams, and constantly told there’s no money for what you need.
The Compensation Package Changed After You Accepted
The commission structure is suddenly different, the bonus criteria have extra conditions that weren’t mentioned, or promised benefits like remote work flexibility have vanished. Any changes to your agreed-upon compensation after you’ve already quit your old job is a serious red flag.
Everyone Seems as Confused as You Are
High turnover, frustrated coworkers, and a general sense that nobody knows what’s going on suggests this isn’t just your experience. When you discover others were also misled, it reveals a pattern of deceptive hiring practices.
Trust your gut. If something feels fundamentally wrong beyond normal adjustment period jitters, you’re probably right.
What Should You Do if You’ve Been ‘Career Catfished’ by an Employer?
Discovering you’ve been deceived can be frustrating and even demoralizing. Before you quit, take a measured and strategic approach to reclaim control of your professional career.
Document Everything
Start keeping detailed records of the discrepancies between what was promised and what you’re actually experiencing. Save the original job posting, offer letter, and any emails or messages that outlined expectations. Write down specific examples of broken promises with dates and details. This documentation protects you and provides clear evidence if you need to have difficult conversations or make formal complaints later.
Have an Honest Conversation With Your Manager
Schedule a private meeting with your supervisor to address your concerns directly. Approach the conversation professionally and avoid being accusatory. Explain the gaps between what you were told during hiring and what you’re experiencing now. Sometimes miscommunications happen, or circumstances change unexpectedly. Your manager may not even realize the problem exists and might be willing to make adjustments.
Escalate to HR if Necessary
If your manager is unresponsive or part of the problem, take your concerns to Human Resources. Present your documentation and explain how the actual job differs from what was advertised. HR exists to protect the company, but addressing deceptive hiring practices is in their interest too. They may be able to transfer you to a different team, adjust your responsibilities, or find another solution.
Set Clear Boundaries and Expectations
While you’re figuring out your next steps, protect your well-being by setting firm boundaries. Don’t let yourself be taken advantage of just because you feel stuck. Clarify your role, push back on unreasonable demands, and insist on the resources you need to do your job properly. You’re under no obligation to accept a situation that was misrepresented to you.
Start Looking for New Opportunities
You don’t have to stay in a job built on deception. Update your resume and begin a careful job search. This time, you’ll know better questions to ask and warning signs to watch for. Look for companies with transparent cultures and consistent reviews. During interviews, ask to speak with potential teammates, request detailed role descriptions, and inquire about recent changes in the department.
Know When to Cut Your Losses
Sometimes the best decision is to leave quickly, especially if the situation is affecting your mental health or career development. There’s no shame in a short job stint when you were misled. If you’ve tried to address the issues and nothing has changed, or if the company’s practices are unethical, prioritize your well-being and move on. In future interviews, you can honestly explain that the role wasn’t as advertised.
Learn From the Experience
Use this situation to sharpen your evaluation skills for next time. Research companies thoroughly before applying. Check employee reviews on sites like Glassdoor. Ask pointed questions during interviews about turnover rates, why the position is open, and what a typical day looks like. Request to see where you’d be working and meet potential colleagues. The more information you gather upfront, the harder it is for employers to deceive you.
Being career catfished doesn’t reflect badly on you—it reflects badly on the employer. Take action to improve your situation, but don’t let this experience make you cynical about your entire career. Better opportunities with honest employers do exist.
You Might Also Enjoy:
EA and Beyond 
Leave a comment